Legal Articles, Written to Be Understood.
Insights and articles on legal matters—written in a clear, straightforward style for those who seek understanding, not persuasion.
Best Lawyer in UAE: 12 Criteria for Choosing the Right Lawyer
Choosing the right lawyer is one of the most important factors influencing the success of your case. Therefore, several criteria should be considered before making a decision. Among the most important of these criteria are: Experience in the type of case. Professional reputation. Clear communication. Transparency in procedures and fees. The ability to provide practical legal solutions. A professional lawyer's role is not limited to representing clients before the relevant authorities; they also provide legal advice that helps you make the right decision and protect your interests.
Read Article
The Personal Status Law in the UAE: Legislative development that protects the family and rights
Personal status law is one of the most important laws directly affecting individuals' lives, as it regulates family matters and related issues such as marriage, divorce, alimony, child custody, guardianship, wills, estates, and inheritance. In the United Arab Emirates, this law has received considerable attention because the family is the foundation of society, and its stability reflects on the stability of children and society as a whole. The modern federal regulation of personal status matters began with Federal Law No. (28) of 2005 concerning personal status, which for many years formed the primary legal framework for family issues. It encompassed matters of marriage, divorce, alimony, child custody, inheritance, and other family-related issues. The UAE Legislation website shows that this law has undergone several legislative amendments in subsequent years. As society evolved and its needs diversified, the UAE introduced more modern and flexible legislation, including Federal Decree-Law No. (41) of 2022 concerning Civil Personal Status. This law established a specific framework for civil personal status matters and came into effect on February 1, 2023, reflecting the UAE's commitment to regulating the status of residents and non-Muslims within a clear legal framework. Following this, a significant legislative step was taken with the issuance of Federal Decree-Law No. (41) of 2024 concerning the Personal Status Law. This modern law was issued on October 1, 2024, and entered into force on April 15, 2025, representing one of the most prominent legislative developments in the field of family law within the country. This evolution demonstrates that the UAE legislator does not treat personal status law as a fixed and unchanging text, but rather as a legal system open to modernization in order to achieve justice, safeguard the family's interests, protect the rights of spouses, and prioritize the well-being of children. Personal status cases are not merely documents in a case file; Rather, it concerns the lives of families, the future of children, financial rights, and delicate social and psychological considerations. Therefore, dealing with these matters requires a deep legal understanding, wisdom in conflict management, and the ability to analyze the case from all angles. Among the most frequently encountered issues in practice are divorce cases, alimony, child custody, visitation rights, establishing marital rights, relinquishing or transferring custody, in addition to inheritance cases, including the division of estates, wills, and disputes arising among heirs. This underscores the importance of consulting a lawyer specializing in this field, as errors at the outset of the case or poor organization of claims can significantly impact the outcome, especially in cases where family rights intersect with financial rights, such as alimony, housing, deferred dowry, custody, or estate division. Lawyer and consultant Ali Saeed Al Shamsi possesses extensive experience in personal status and inheritance cases, having handled various family and legal disputes. He understands the nature of these cases, which demand legal precision, a calm approach, and a commitment to reaching the most suitable solution for his client. Ultimately, being aware of personal status law doesn't mean waiting for a dispute to arise, but rather knowing your rights and obligations before making any important decision, whether before marriage, during divorce, when claiming alimony, or when opening an inheritance case. The law in the UAE has evolved to protect the family and its rights, but benefiting from this protection begins with proper legal advice at the right time. [See the full article in Arabic.]
Read Article
Law in the United Arab Emirates: A System That Protects Rights and Regulates Life
Law in the United Arab Emirates is not merely a collection of rules and penalties applied when disputes arise. Rather, it is an integrated legal system designed to regulate different aspects of life, protect rights, define obligations, and maintain a balance between individual interests and the public interest. The UAE legal system is founded on a clear constitutional framework. The Constitution establishes the general foundations of the State, regulates the exercise of public authority, and sets out fundamental principles that support justice, equality, and the rule of law. UAE legislation extends across many aspects of daily life. It regulates family matters, employment relationships, commercial activities, contracts, civil liability, criminal conduct, judicial procedures, and activities conducted through modern digital technologies. In civil transactions, the law regulates relationships between individuals and addresses obligations, contracts, compensation, and civil liability. These matters directly affect everyday life, as many disputes may arise from unclear contractual terms, verbal agreements, failure to document obligations properly, or disagreement over the performance of contractual duties. In the criminal field, UAE legislation protects individuals and society against conduct that may affect security, property, personal rights, reputation, or dignity. Criminal law is not concerned with punishment alone; it also seeks to protect society, deter unlawful conduct, safeguard rights, and achieve justice. The rapid development of digital technology has also increased the importance of legal awareness. UAE legislation addresses cybercrimes and the misuse of digital platforms. A message, photograph, video, online publication, or other digital activity may have legal consequences when it unlawfully infringes privacy, reputation, personal data, or other legally protected rights. Employment relationships are also subject to detailed legal regulation. UAE legislation defines many of the rights and obligations of workers and employers and provides a legal framework for matters such as wages, leave, termination of employment, workplace obligations, and the resolution of labour disputes. Family relationships receive particular attention through personal status legislation, which regulates matters such as marriage, divorce, maintenance, custody, and other family rights and obligations in accordance with the applicable legal framework. The law also regulates the process of claiming and protecting rights before the courts. Civil procedure legislation establishes the legal mechanisms and procedures through which disputes are brought before the judiciary. Having a legal right may not, by itself, be sufficient if the correct procedure for asserting and protecting that right is not followed. In the commercial field, UAE legislation regulates companies, commercial transactions, business relationships, and the rights and obligations arising from them. Successful business relationships should not depend on trust alone; clear contracts and proper legal arrangements are essential for reducing risks and protecting the interests of all parties. Ultimately, law in the United Arab Emirates is closely connected to everyday life. It affects family relationships, employment, contracts, businesses, court proceedings, and activities in the digital world. Legal awareness should therefore not begin only after a dispute arises; understanding legal rights and obligations can help prevent disputes before they occur. For this reason, seeking legal advice at an early stage may be important before signing a contract, entering into a partnership, publishing content, undertaking a significant transaction, or making a decision that may have legal consequences. Legal awareness is not merely about knowing the law after a problem occurs; it is also about understanding your rights and obligations before making decisions that may affect them.
Read Article
When Do You Need a Lawyer? 7 Situations Where Legal Advice Is Essential
Many legal problems begin as simple issues but quickly become complicated if not handled properly. Seeking legal advice early can protect your rights, reduce risks, and help you make informed decisions. You should consult a lawyer when dealing with: Business disputes Contract drafting and review Family law matters Criminal cases Financial claims Company formation Real estate disputes Professional legal guidance saves time, money, and unnecessary legal complications.
Read Article
Lawyer in Abu Dhabi | How to Choose the Right Lawyer in the UAE?
If you are looking for a lawyer in Abu Dhabi, choosing the right lawyer should not be based solely on legal fees or reputation. The lawyer’s specialization, experience in handling similar cases, and ability to analyze facts and documents are important factors when determining the appropriate legal strategy under UAE law. Legal matters vary significantly. Criminal cases require a different approach from civil, commercial, real estate, corporate, contractual, and family law matters. Therefore, one of the first steps is to choose a lawyer whose experience is relevant to the nature of your case. When choosing a lawyer in Abu Dhabi or Dubai, consider the lawyer’s specialization, practical legal experience, professional licensing, ability to assess documents and evidence, clarity regarding legal fees and the scope of representation, and familiarity with the relevant courts and procedures. Whether you are searching for a lawyer in Abu Dhabi, a lawyer in Dubai, or legal services in the UAE, the appropriate choice should ultimately depend on the nature of your case and the lawyer’s relevant experience.
Read Article
The Difference Between Insult and Defamation in UAE Law : Penalties and Cybercrime
The Difference Between Insult and Defamation in UAE Law: Penalties and Cybercrime What is the difference between insult and defamation in the UAE? Although the terms insult and defamation are sometimes used interchangeably, UAE law distinguishes between them, and that distinction may affect the legal characterization of the offence, the applicable legal provision, and the penalty. The fundamental difference can be summarized as follows: Defamation involves attributing a specific fact to a person that may expose that person to punishment or contempt, while insult involves harming a person’s honour or dignity without attributing a specific fact. However, determining whether a statement constitutes insult or defamation does not depend on the words alone. The content, context, manner in which the statement was made, means of communication, and available evidence must all be considered. Therefore, it is not enough to ask: What did the person say? It is also necessary to ask: What was attributed to the person? How was it said? To whom? Through what means? And what evidence is available? The Difference Between Insult and Defamation in Brief Defamation: Involves attributing a specific fact to a person that may expose that person to punishment or contempt. Insult: Involves harming a person’s honour or dignity without attributing a specific fact. The first practical question when examining a case is: Was a specific act or fact attributed to the person, or was the statement limited to insulting or harming that person’s honour or dignity? However, answering this question alone is not sufficient, because the context, means of communication, and manner in which the act was committed may affect the applicable legal provision. What is Defamation Under UAE Law? Defamation is regulated under Article 425 of Federal Decree-Law No. 31 of 2021 Promulgating the Crimes and Penalties Law, as amended. In essence, defamation involves attributing a fact to another person that would expose that person to punishment or contempt, provided that the other legal elements required by law are satisfied. The important distinguishing element is therefore the attribution of a specific fact. The legal assessment does not depend merely on how offended the victim feels. It depends on the content of the statement, its meaning, and the circumstances in which it was made. What is the Penalty for Defamation in the UAE? Under Article 425, defamation in the circumstances specified by the Article is punishable by imprisonment for a period not exceeding two years or a fine not exceeding AED 20,000. The Article also contains specific provisions where defamation is committed against a public official or a person entrusted with a public service during, because of, or in connection with the performance of their duties, or where the statement affects honour, harms the reputation of families, or is intended to achieve an unlawful purpose. Defamation committed through publication in newspapers or printed materials is considered an aggravating circumstance. What is Insult Under UAE Law? The essential distinction between insult and defamation is the absence of attribution of a specific fact. Article 426 of the UAE Crimes and Penalties Law addresses publicly directing statements against another person that harm that person’s honour or dignity without attributing a specific fact. The distinction can therefore be summarized as: Defamation = attribution of a specific fact. Insult = harm to honour or dignity without attribution of a specific fact. However, an offence should not be classified merely by taking one word out of an entire conversation. The complete statement and the context in which it was made should be examined. What is the Penalty for Insult in the UAE? Under Article 426, insult in the basic circumstances specified by the Article is punishable by imprisonment for a period not exceeding one year or a fine not exceeding AED 20,000. The Article also provides for other circumstances depending on the status of the victim, nature of the insult, and circumstances surrounding the act. Example of the Difference Between Insult and Defamation Suppose a person directs an offensive description at another person that harms their honour or dignity but does not attribute any specific act or fact to them. This may constitute insult, provided that the remaining legal elements are satisfied. If, however, a specific fact is attributed to that person which may expose them to punishment or contempt, the conduct may constitute defamation. These examples are illustrative only and do not determine the legal characterization of any particular case. The law assesses the entire incident rather than an isolated word. Is Every Offensive Statement Considered Insult or Defamation? No. Not every disagreement, criticism, or inappropriate statement between two people necessarily constitutes the criminal offence of insult or defamation. The legal characterization may depend on several factors, including the content of the statement, its meaning, context, publicity where required by law, method of communication, status of the parties, available evidence, and other surrounding circumstances. Two statements may therefore appear linguistically similar while receiving different legal classifications. Insult and Defamation by Telephone or Private Messages Article 427 contains specific provisions concerning certain forms of insult and defamation committed by telephone, directly in the presence of the victim, or through a message. This distinction is important because the manner in which the conduct occurred may affect the applicable legal provision and penalty. There is therefore no single penalty that can automatically be applied to every insult or defamation case without first determining how the conduct occurred and what means were used. What is the Penalty for Online Insult and Defamation in the UAE? Where an information network, information technology means, or information system is used, the provisions of Federal Decree-Law No. 34 of 2021 on Combating Rumours and Cybercrimes must also be considered. Article 43 criminalizes insulting another person or attributing a fact to another person that would expose that person to punishment or contempt by others through the means specified in the Article. The penalty under Article 43 is: Imprisonment and a fine of not less than AED 250,000 and not more than AED 500,000, or either of these two penalties. Where the offence is committed against a public official or a person entrusted with a public service because of or in connection with the performance of their duties, this constitutes an aggravating circumstance. For a detailed explanation, read: Penalty for Online Insult and Defamation in the UAE via WhatsApp and Social Media https://alilaw.ae/ar/articles/19 Insult and Defamation via WhatsApp in the UAE A common question is: Is insulting someone on WhatsApp a crime in the UAE? Using WhatsApp does not place a statement outside the scope of the law. The incident may involve a private message, a WhatsApp group, an audio recording, an image, or other electronic content. However, it would also be inaccurate to assume that every incident occurring through WhatsApp automatically receives the same legal treatment. The content of the message, sender, recipient, method of transmission, context, evidence, and manner in which the conduct occurred should first be examined before determining the applicable legal provision. Insult and Defamation on Instagram, Snapchat and Social Media Offensive conduct may occur through a post, comment, private message, image, video, social-media account, or another information technology means. Where information technology is used, the applicability of the UAE Cybercrime Law must be considered. Deleting a post or message afterwards does not necessarily mean that all evidence relating to the incident has disappeared. It is therefore important to preserve evidence lawfully and avoid altering or tampering with it. How Do You Prove Insult or Defamation in the UAE? Evidence is a fundamental element of the case. Depending on the circumstances, evidence may include messages and conversations, posts and comments, digital evidence, witness testimony, documents, data associated with the conduct, and other lawful means of proof. However, possessing a screenshot does not automatically resolve every evidentiary issue. Questions may arise concerning the source of the evidence, attribution to its alleged author, completeness, context, and legal significance. For a detailed explanation, read: How to Prove Insult and Defamation in the UAE: Evidence and Time Limit for Filing a Complaint https://alilaw.ae/ar/articles/20 How Do I File an Insult or Defamation Complaint in the UAE? If a person believes that they have been subjected to insult or defamation, the available evidence should first be preserved. It is also advisable not to respond with another offensive statement that could result in mutual allegations. The location and manner of the incident should then be identified, including whether it occurred directly, by telephone, or electronically, followed by determining the competent authority and appropriate legal procedure. Certain complaints may be subject to procedural requirements and time limits. Therefore, a person intending to take legal action should not unnecessarily delay examining the matter. For further details regarding evidence, complaint periods, and related procedures, read: How to Prove Insult and Defamation in the UAE: Evidence and Time Limit for Filing a Complaint https://alilaw.ae/ar/articles/20 Are Insult and Defamation Cases Different in Abu Dhabi, Dubai and Sharjah? The criminal provisions discussed in this article are federal legislation. Therefore, the fact that an incident occurs in Abu Dhabi, Dubai, Sharjah, Al Ain, or another Emirate or city does not by itself create a different legal definition of insult or defamation. However, jurisdiction, the competent authority, and applicable procedures may depend on the location and nature of the incident and the relevant procedural rules. Can Insult and Defamation Cases Be Settled Amicably? The UAE Criminal Procedures Law includes offences under Articles 425, 426 and 427 of the Crimes and Penalties Law among the offences for which criminal reconciliation may be permitted in accordance with the applicable legal provisions. Therefore, examining a case does not always end with the question of punishment. It may also be necessary to determine whether reconciliation is legally available and what effect it may have at the particular stage of proceedings. Does Proving That a Statement is True Prevent Defamation Liability? Not necessarily. It is inaccurate to apply a general rule stating: “If the statement is true, there is no defamation.” Article 428 regulates a specific situation concerning proof of the truth of an attributed fact where the attribution concerns a public official or a person entrusted with a public service and relates to their office or service, subject to the legal requirements stated in the Article. Therefore, a person’s belief that what they said was true does not automatically eliminate liability in every defamation case. Is Reporting an Incident to the Police or Competent Authorities Defamation? Not every report made to a competent authority constitutes defamation. Article 430 provides a rule concerning good-faith reporting to judicial or administrative authorities of a matter that may give rise to responsibility on the part of its perpetrator. This again demonstrates the importance of context, purpose, and the recipient of the statement. Reporting a matter to a competent authority is different from publishing an accusation to the general public. Can Statements Made Before a Court Constitute Insult or Defamation? Article 429 addresses statements made within the exercise of the right of defence before courts or investigating authorities. The requirement that such statements remain within the limits of the right of defence is important. The provision should not be understood as unrestricted permission to insult others beyond what is necessary for exercising the right of defence. Can Compensation Be Claimed for Insult or Defamation? An incident involving insult or defamation may, in addition to criminal liability where its elements are established, give rise to a claim for compensation where damage has occurred and the requirements of civil liability are satisfied. A distinction should be made between: Criminal penalty: concerns the offence and criminal responsibility. Civil compensation: concerns damage, causation, and the other requirements of civil liability. Therefore, filing a criminal complaint or even establishing criminal liability does not automatically mean that a particular amount of compensation will be awarded. Compensation depends on the proven damage, circumstances of the case, and assessment of the court. For further details, read: Compensation for Insult and Defamation in the UAE: When Can a Victim Claim Compensation? https://alilaw.ae/ar/articles/21 Is Calling Someone a “Liar” or “Fraudster” Insult or Defamation? A reliable legal conclusion cannot be reached by examining an isolated word without knowing its context. A word may be used in a manner that attributes a specific fact, may simply operate as an insult or description, or may have an entirely different meaning when the full conversation is considered. Therefore, searching for a fixed list of “insult and defamation words in the UAE” may be misleading. The law assesses the entire incident, not merely an isolated word. Is Criticism Considered Insult or Defamation? Not every criticism constitutes a criminal offence. Expressing an opinion, disagreement, or criticism does not automatically become insult or defamation simply because another person dislikes the statement. The position may differ where the statement goes beyond criticism and harms honour or dignity, or attributes a fact satisfying the elements of an offence. The content and context of the statement therefore remain important. What Should You Do If You Are Accused of Insult or Defamation? A defence should not be built around a single word, nor should messages be deleted or evidence altered. The statement itself, entire conversation, context, means used, manner in which the evidence was obtained, attribution of the content to the accused, and legal provision relied upon should all be examined. It is also necessary to consider whether the incident falls within the provisions concerning defamation, insult, telephone calls and messages, or offences committed through information technology, together with any available legal defences or other provisions relevant to the circumstances. When Do You Need Legal Advice in an Insult or Defamation Case? For a victim, examining the case requires more than determining whether a statement was offensive. Its legal characterization, evidence, procedure, and applicable legal provision must also be considered. For an accused person, one message should not be examined in isolation from the remainder of the conversation. The correct starting point can be summarized in five elements: Statement + Context + Means + Evidence + Applicable Law Frequently Asked Questions About Insult and Defamation in the UAE What is the difference between insult and defamation? Defamation involves attributing a fact to a person that may expose that person to punishment or contempt, while insult involves harming a person’s honour or dignity without attributing a specific fact. What is the penalty for defamation in the UAE? Under Article 425, the penalty in the circumstances specified by the Article may reach imprisonment for a period not exceeding two years or a fine not exceeding AED 20,000, subject to the other circumstances regulated by law. What is the penalty for insult in the UAE? Under Article 426, the basic penalty may reach imprisonment for a period not exceeding one year or a fine not exceeding AED 20,000, subject to the other circumstances regulated by law. What is the penalty for online insult and defamation? Under Article 43 of the UAE Cybercrime Law, the penalty is imprisonment and a fine ranging from AED 250,000 to AED 500,000, or either of these penalties, where the requirements of the Article are satisfied. Is insulting someone on WhatsApp a crime in the UAE? Legal liability may arise from an offensive statement sent through WhatsApp where the elements of the offence are satisfied. The applicable provision and penalty depend on the content, manner of transmission, context, and circumstances of the incident. Does deleting an insulting message end the case? Not necessarily. Deleting content does not automatically eliminate all available evidence, and the existence and evidentiary value of other material will be assessed by the competent authorities. Can an insult or defamation case be settled? Criminal reconciliation may be available for offences specified by UAE law, including offences under Articles 425, 426 and 427, subject to the applicable legal provisions. Can compensation be claimed for insult or defamation? A compensation claim may be considered where the requirements of civil liability are satisfied, including proof of damage and causation. The amount of compensation is determined by the court according to the circumstances of the case. Is the penalty different if the insult occurs online? The applicable legal provision and penalty may differ where an information network or information technology means is used. The means through which the conduct occurred must therefore be identified before determining the applicable provision. Conclusion: How Can You Tell the Difference Between Insult and Defamation? The basic rule can be summarized in one sentence: Defamation involves attributing a specific fact to a person, while insult involves harming that person’s honour or dignity without attributing a specific fact. But this is only the beginning of the legal analysis. Before determining the offence and applicable penalty, it is necessary to establish: What was said? What did the statement mean? What was its context? How was it communicated? Was it made before others or through a private message? Was information technology used? What evidence is available? The linguistic distinction between insult and defamation may appear simple, but legally it may result in a different characterization of the incident, applicable provision, penalty, and procedure. Prepared by: Advocate & Legal Consultant Ali Saeed Al Shamsi This article is provided for general legal awareness and does not replace an independent assessment of the circumstances, documents, and evidence of each case under the laws in force in the United Arab Emirates.
Read Article
Child Custody After Divorce in the UAE: Who Has the Right to Custody and When Can Custody Be Lost?
Child Custody After Divorce in the UAE: Who Has the Right to Custody and When Can Custody Be Lost? Divorce ends the marital relationship, but it does not end motherhood or fatherhood. This is perhaps the most important principle from which any legal discussion of child custody should begin. When spouses separate, each parent may view custody as a right they want to retain. The law, however, looks at the matter from a broader perspective: Where does the best interest of the child lie? Therefore, the correct question is not always: Who wins the custody case, the father or the mother? Rather: With whom will the child’s best interests be better protected? This reflects an important aspect of the philosophy behind modern UAE family legislation. Custody is not a reward granted to one parent, nor is it a means of punishing the other after divorce. It is a legal framework designed primarily to protect, care for, and preserve the stability of the child. The UAE personal status system has undergone significant development with the issuance of Federal Decree-Law No. 41 of 2024 on Personal Status, together with subsequent regulations and decisions aimed at modernising family justice and strengthening the protection of children. What Does Child Custody Mean Under UAE Law? Custody does not simply mean that the child lives in the home of the father or mother. It is a responsibility that includes protecting, caring for, raising, and attending to the affairs of the child in a manner that serves the child’s best interests. It is therefore important to distinguish custody from other rights and obligations relating to children. The fact that a child is in the custody of one parent does not mean that the other parent’s role in the child’s life has ended. Likewise, the termination of the marital relationship does not terminate the legal and family responsibilities of either parent toward their children. One of the mistakes that can occur after divorce is allowing previous marital disputes to become disputes over the children. The child was never a party to the conflict between the parents and should not become a means of continuing that conflict after divorce. Who Is Entitled to Custody After Divorce in the UAE? UAE Personal Status Law regulates the order of persons entitled to custody. The mother and then the father are at the forefront of this order, followed by other eligible persons in accordance with the sequence and conditions established by law. However, reading the custody provisions solely on the basis of this order is not sufficient. Custody is subject to legal conditions that the custodian must satisfy, while the best interests of the child remain among the most important considerations examined by the court when deciding a custody dispute. For this reason, two cases may appear similar but result in different judgments. The circumstances of the child and family, each parent’s ability to provide care, and the environment in which the child will live may differ significantly from one case to another. Custody Is Not an Absolute Right of Either Parent One of the most common misconceptions in family disputes is: “The mother always gets custody.” Others may believe that once a child reaches a particular age, custody automatically transfers to the father. Approaching custody cases in such simplified terms may lead to legally inaccurate conclusions. There is a statutory order of entitlement, legal conditions applicable to custodians, circumstances that may affect the continuation of custody, and, above all, the individual circumstances and best interests of the child. The outcome of a custody case should therefore never be predicted merely on the basis of the experience of a friend or relative. Every custody case has its own facts, circumstances and evidence. When Can Custody Be Lost? Loss of custody does not occur merely because one parent makes allegations against the other. A person seeking the removal of custody must rely on a legally relevant ground and must be able to establish the facts supporting that claim. The law regulates the conditions required of a custodian and the circumstances that may affect entitlement to or continuation of custody. An important distinction must therefore be made between: A dispute between the parents, and A circumstance that genuinely affects the child’s best interests or the legal conditions required for custody. Not every disagreement between divorced parents is a ground for removing custody. Likewise, not every act that annoys the other parent necessarily means that the custodian is no longer fit to care for the child. The relevant consideration is not the intensity of the conflict between the parents, but the effect of the circumstances on the child and whether the statutory custody requirements remain satisfied. Does the Mother’s Remarriage Automatically End Her Custody? This is one of the most frequently asked questions in custody disputes. It is also an area in which simplified legal information, sometimes based on previous legislation or earlier legal practice, is frequently circulated. The remarriage of a female custodian should not be considered in isolation from the applicable legal provisions, the circumstances of the case, and the best interests of the child. A custody dispute cannot properly be decided by the simple statement: “The mother remarried, therefore her custody has ended.” The court must consider the relevant custody requirements, the circumstances of the child, the new family situation, and whether continuation or transfer of custody serves the child’s best interests under the law. For this reason, caution should be exercised before applying the outcome of one custody judgment to every other case. Different facts may produce a different legal result. Can the Father Obtain Custody? Yes, where the legal requirements and circumstances establishing his entitlement to custody are satisfied. Under the new Personal Status Law, the father is among those at the forefront of the statutory order of custodians following the mother. However, the existence of a dispute with the mother alone is not sufficient to obtain custody. In a serious custody dispute, the more important question becomes: What facts affect the child’s best interests, and can those facts be proven? A strong custody case is therefore not built on the number of accusations exchanged between the parents. It is built on relevant facts and evidence directly connected to the welfare of the child. The Best Interests of the Child Are More Than a Legal Phrase The expression “best interests of the child” appears frequently in family cases and may sometimes sound like a broad or abstract legal principle. In reality, it can be at the very heart of a custody dispute. A judge does not live with the family and cannot know every detail of its daily life except through the facts and evidence presented before the court. Accordingly, factors such as stability, care, education, supervision, the child’s living environment, and potential harm may become relevant depending on the circumstances of each case. This is where evidence becomes crucial. One party may have a long story but little evidence. Another may rely on only a few facts, but those facts may be clear, proven, and directly connected to the welfare of the child. In litigation, a narrative alone is not enough. The court must consider what can actually be established by evidence and what legal consequences follow from those facts. Does a Custody Judgment Last Forever? Custody is connected to the circumstances existing when the judgment is issued. Those circumstances may later change in a way that affects either the child’s best interests or the custodian’s ability to satisfy the legal requirements of custody. Therefore, the issuance of a custody judgment at a particular point in time does not necessarily mean that circumstances can never change in the future. This reflects the particular nature of family disputes. They concern real people whose circumstances change, children who grow older, and educational, social and living needs that may develop over time. Travelling With a Child After Divorce Travel involving children can quickly become a serious dispute between divorced parents. It should not be assumed that having custody gives one parent an unrestricted right to travel with or relocate the child without considering the applicable legal requirements. UAE Personal Status Law regulates matters relating to travelling with a child and the corresponding rights and restrictions. Where a genuine dispute exists regarding travel or relocation outside the UAE, it may be far better to address the matter legally before taking a step that could create a much larger dispute. In child travel cases, obtaining legal clarity before travelling can be considerably easier than attempting to resolve the consequences afterwards. Who Decides the Child’s Education? Education is another practical issue that frequently arises after separation. Which school should the child attend? Who should supervise the child’s education? What happens when the parents disagree over an important educational decision? These matters may appear straightforward while the family remains together, but after divorce they can become a continuing source of conflict. The child’s educational welfare and stability should remain more important than either parent’s attempt to impose their position on the other. Where a serious disagreement affects the child’s education, the appropriate legal route should be considered rather than allowing the dispute to continue at the expense of the child’s future. Visitation Should Never Become a Tool of Revenge One of the most damaging mistakes following divorce is using visitation or contact with the child as a means of pressure. A custodian may believe that preventing contact with the other parent represents a form of victory. The other parent may attempt to use visitation as an opportunity to reopen old marital disputes. In both situations, the child pays the price. The UAE family law system has introduced modern regulations relating to visitation, family guidance and other procedures intended to improve the resolution of family disputes and protect children. Visitation is not merely a privilege that one parent may grant or withdraw from the other whenever they wish. It forms part of a legal framework designed to preserve the child’s relationship with both parents after the marital relationship has ended. Does Custody End the Other Parent’s Rights? No. This is where emotions must be separated from the law. The marriage may end, but the child’s relationship with both parents does not end with the divorce judgment. The law therefore regulates custody, visitation, maintenance and other rights and obligations as interconnected aspects of family responsibility. A common mistake is attempting to exchange one right for another. Visitation, for example, should not become leverage in a maintenance dispute, nor should maintenance be used as pressure in a custody dispute. Each issue has its own legal basis. Ultimately, the child’s welfare should not be lost in the conflict between adults. Maintenance and Custody: Are They the Same Thing? No. Custody and maintenance are separate legal matters, although they frequently arise together in family disputes. The fact that a child lives in the custody of one parent does not eliminate financial obligations toward the child under the law. Similarly, a dispute concerning maintenance does not automatically terminate custody or visitation rights. Each claim should therefore be examined according to its own legal basis rather than treating every family disagreement as a single issue. What Changed Under the New UAE Personal Status Law? The UAE introduced a significant modernisation of its personal status framework through Federal Decree-Law No. 41 of 2024 on Personal Status. The development did not stop with the issuance of the legislation itself. It has been accompanied by regulations and decisions concerning the implementation of the new family law framework, including matters relating to family guidance, child visitation and family procedures. These developments demonstrate a broader legislative direction toward clearer regulation of family relationships, more efficient resolution of disputes, stronger protection of children, and reducing, as far as possible, the risk that marital conflict becomes a prolonged dispute in which children bear the consequences. A Common Mistake: Turning a Custody Case Into a Case Against the Other Parent A large volume of documents does not necessarily make a case stronger. One parent may produce dozens of messages, photographs and conversations in an attempt to prove that the marriage was unhappy. But the more important question is: What do those facts have to do with custody and the welfare of the child? In custody disputes, three matters should be distinguished: 1. The conflict between the spouses. 2. The ability and suitability of each parent to fulfil custody responsibilities. 3. The best interests of the child. A marriage may have reached a point where continuing the relationship became impossible, while both parents remain caring, responsible and capable of fulfilling their duties toward their children. Turning every marital disagreement into a custody allegation may therefore distract from, rather than strengthen, the real legal case. Before Seeking the Removal of Custody Before taking such a step, several important questions should be considered: Is there a legally relevant circumstance? Can it be proven? Does it genuinely affect the child’s welfare or the legal requirements for custody? And if custody is transferred, what alternative arrangement would better serve the child? The final question is particularly important. Removing custody from one person is not the end of the matter. The child still requires someone to provide care and a stable environment in which to live. It is therefore not enough to explain why one parent objects to the other. The court must be presented with a complete picture of what arrangement actually serves the child’s best interests. Custody Is Not a Battle Between a Man and a Woman This may be the most important conclusion. When custody becomes a personal battle, each parent may become focused on proving that the other is wrong. In the middle of that conflict, the person whom the entire custody system was created to protect may be forgotten: The child. The law can define rights and obligations. The court can issue judgments concerning custody, visitation and maintenance. But a court judgment alone cannot create a healthy relationship between divorced parents for the benefit of their child. That responsibility ultimately belongs to the mother and father. Divorce may end the marriage, but it should not turn the child into a means of continuing the conflict. The best outcome in a family dispute is not always the one in which one parent receives everything they requested. Sometimes, the best outcome is the one in which the child emerges with the least possible harm from the parents’ separation. Marriage may end by divorce. Motherhood and fatherhood do not end by court judgment. --- Prepared by: Advocate & Legal Consultant Ali Saeed Al Shamsi This article is provided for general legal awareness and does not constitute legal advice. Each case should be assessed independently according to its particular facts, documents and the legislation in force in the United Arab Emirates.
Read Article
Best Criminal Lawyer in Abu Dhabi and the UAE: How to Choose a Criminal Defense Lawyer
Best Criminal Lawyer in Abu Dhabi and the UAE: How to Choose a Criminal Defense Lawyer When someone searches for the “best criminal lawyer in Abu Dhabi,” a “criminal lawyer in the UAE,” or a “drug crimes lawyer in Abu Dhabi,” they are usually not looking for a title. They may be facing a case that affects their liberty, reputation, or future. They may be at the preliminary inquiry stage, under investigation by the Public Prosecution, facing trial, or seeking to understand the legal remedies available after a judgment has been issued. Therefore, the most important question is not: Who is the most famous criminal lawyer? Rather: Who is the right lawyer for this particular case, at this particular stage, based on the evidence contained in the case file? A criminal case cannot be properly understood merely from the name of the charge. It must be examined through: Facts + Procedure + Evidence + Legal Classification. A single point in an investigation report, search procedure, or forensic report may have greater significance than dozens of pages of written submissions. This is why effective criminal defense begins with reading and understanding the case file. What Is a Criminal Lawyer? A criminal lawyer handles criminal cases through their various stages, beginning with preliminary inquiries and investigations, continuing through trial, and extending to appeals and further challenges where legally available. The proper examination of a criminal case does not begin with the question: What is the punishment? Several questions must come first: What conduct is attributed to the accused? How is that conduct legally classified? What evidence exists? How was the evidence obtained? What procedures were followed? Are there forensic reports or digital evidence? What stage has the case reached? Answering these questions is the proper starting point for assessing a criminal case. How Do You Choose the Best Criminal Lawyer in Abu Dhabi? There is no official authority that awards a lawyer the title of the “best criminal lawyer in Abu Dhabi” or the “best criminal lawyer in the UAE.” Such a title should therefore not be the basis on which a lawyer is selected. The real measure lies in how the lawyer approaches the case. Does the lawyer ask to review the documents before giving a final opinion? Does the lawyer distinguish between what the parties say and what the evidence can actually prove? Does the lawyer examine arrest, search, and investigation procedures? Does the lawyer explain the stage the case has reached? Does the lawyer identify both strengths and weaknesses? Does the lawyer clearly discuss available legal options and risks? And does the lawyer avoid guaranteeing an outcome that only the judiciary has the authority to determine? A good lawyer does not merely tell a client what the client wants to hear. A good lawyer explains what the client needs to know about their legal position. What Does Specialization in Criminal Cases Mean? A criminal case does not begin in the courtroom. It may begin with a complaint, a case of flagrante delicto, an arrest, or a summons. It may then proceed through evidence gathering and investigation by the Public Prosecution before potentially being referred to the competent court, depending on the outcome of the investigation and the legal classification of the alleged conduct. Federal Decree-Law No. 38 of 2022 Promulgating the Criminal Procedure Law regulates various stages and procedures relating to arrest, search, investigation, trial, and defense rights. This demonstrates why a criminal lawyer should examine the case from its beginning rather than focusing only on the potential penalty. What Types of Cases Does a Criminal Lawyer Handle? Criminal cases cover a wide range of conduct depending on the facts and applicable legislation, including: Drug and psychotropic substance cases. Fraud and financial crimes. Forgery and use of forged documents. Theft and breach of trust. Assault and offenses against persons. Insult and defamation cases. Cybercrime cases. Threat-related offenses. And other criminal offenses regulated by the laws in force in the United Arab Emirates. However, the fact that two matters are both classified as “criminal cases” does not mean that the same defense strategy applies to both. Every case has its own facts, evidence, circumstances, and legal classification. How Does a Criminal Lawyer Examine a Case File? There is no single defense memorandum that is suitable for every criminal case. A proper assessment begins by developing a complete understanding of the case file. Depending on the nature of the case, the review may include: Police and preliminary inquiry reports. Investigation records. Arrest procedures. Search procedures. Seized items. Procedures relating to the preservation and sealing of evidence. Forensic and laboratory reports. Statements of the accused. Witness statements. Documents. Correspondence and communications. Recordings. Digital evidence. The judgment and its reasoning if the case has reached the appeal stage. The next and most important step is to connect the facts to the evidence, the evidence to the procedure, and then determine the applicable legal provision and legal classification. Arrest of an Accused Person Under UAE Law An arrest should not be examined in isolation from the rest of the criminal case. The UAE Criminal Procedure Law specifies the circumstances in which a judicial police officer may arrest an accused person, including the circumstances set out in Article 46. The law also regulates the procedures and safeguards applicable after arrest, including the questioning of the arrested person and referral to the Public Prosecution. Accordingly, examining a case may require asking: How was the arrest carried out? On what legal basis? What happened after the arrest? What was recorded in the official reports? What occurs at the beginning of a criminal case may affect later stages of the proceedings. Search Procedures Under UAE Law Search procedures are important in many criminal cases, particularly those involving seized items or physical evidence. The Criminal Procedure Law regulates searches of persons and premises as well as the seizure of items. Article 54 regulates matters concerning the search of an accused person’s residence and the authorization of the Public Prosecution, subject to the circumstances and exceptions prescribed by law. Therefore, in some cases, the question is not merely: Was evidence found? It may also be necessary to ask: How was the evidence found? Where was it found? What was the legal basis for the procedure that led to its seizure? This does not mean that a search should automatically be presumed valid or invalid. The facts, official records, and legal basis of the procedure must first be reviewed before reaching a legal conclusion. The Lawyer’s Presence During Investigation The Criminal Procedure Law regulates the presence of the accused person’s lawyer during the investigation. It also regulates the lawyer’s access to case papers in accordance with the provisions and limitations prescribed by law. The law further regulates the appointment of defense counsel for an accused person in the felony cases specified by law. This confirms that defense rights do not begin only after a judgment is issued. They form part of the criminal procedure system itself. Why Is Evidence Central to a Criminal Case? The account given by an accused person or complainant is important for understanding what happened, but it does not constitute the entire case file. The more important question is: What can the evidence actually prove? A person may believe that one particular issue is the most important part of the case, only for a review of the file to reveal that the case depends on a completely different issue. The dispute may concern attribution of the act to the accused. It may concern intent. It may concern forensic evidence. It may concern a procedural issue. Or it may concern the legal classification of the conduct. Criminal defense should therefore not be built on a first impression. It should be built on the case file. Drug Crimes Lawyer in Abu Dhabi and the UAE When someone searches for a “drug crimes lawyer in Abu Dhabi” or a “drug crimes lawyer in the UAE,” the case is often at a sensitive stage. However, describing a matter simply as a “drug case” is not enough to assess it. Federal Decree-Law No. 30 of 2021 on Combating Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances, as amended, regulates matters concerning narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances, prohibited conduct, penalties, and related measures. The legislation in force at the time the particular matter is examined must therefore be considered. Drug cases may differ according to: The conduct attributed to the accused. The type of substance. The circumstances of seizure. The evidence. Intent. The attribution of seized substances to the accused. And the legal classification of the alleged conduct. Drug cases therefore cannot all be treated as if they were the same. Drug Use, Possession, Promotion, and Trafficking Are Not the Same Legal Classification One common mistake is to place every drug-related case under a single description. The presence of a narcotic drug or psychotropic substance in a particular case does not mean that all possible legal classifications are equivalent. It is first necessary to identify the conduct that the Public Prosecution alleges was committed by the accused and then examine the facts, evidence, intent, and applicable legal provisions. A lawyer handling a drug case should therefore not ask only: What was the quantity? Other questions may include: To whom are the seized substances attributed? Where were they found? How were they seized? How were they preserved and sealed? What does the forensic examination show? What statements are contained in the case file? Are there messages, communications, transfers, or other evidence? What exactly does that evidence establish? Seized Items and Preservation of Evidence in Criminal Cases In cases that depend heavily on physical evidence, the way items were seized, described, preserved, and sealed may form part of the examination of the case file. A lawyer should not assume that there is a procedural defect. Nor should every procedure be assumed valid without examination. The records and procedures should be reviewed against the applicable law to determine whether there is a legal issue that genuinely affects the case. This is the difference between a defense based on the actual case file and one based on general arguments. Is the Mere Presence of Drugs Sufficient for Conviction? This question should not be answered in absolute terms without knowing the facts of the case. The presence of a substance may constitute important evidence, but criminal liability must be examined in light of the conduct attributed to the accused, the evidence, the connection between the accused and the alleged conduct, the required intent, and the elements of the relevant offense. The case file should therefore be reviewed before providing a precise legal assessment. Cybercrime Lawyer in the UAE Criminal evidence is no longer limited to paper documents or witness testimony. Many criminal cases today may involve: WhatsApp messages. Electronic conversations. Social media accounts. Images. Recordings. Voice messages. Or other digital data and evidence. This may raise questions such as: Who owns the account? Can the message or content be attributed to that person? Is the conversation complete? What is the context? What is the legal significance of the content? For more information on cybercrime and digital evidence: The Difference Between Insult and Defamation Under UAE Law: Penalties and Cybercrime https://alilaw.ae/en/articles/16 Penalties for Online Insult and Defamation in the UAE Through WhatsApp and Social Media https://alilaw.ae/en/articles/19 How to Prove Insult and Defamation in the UAE: Evidence and the Time Limit for Filing a Complaint https://alilaw.ae/en/articles/20 Criminal Lawyer During Public Prosecution Investigation The Public Prosecution forms part of the judicial authority and carries out criminal investigations and prosecutions in accordance with the law. The investigation stage is an important part of a criminal case. It may involve statements, questioning, reports, evidence, and other procedures permitted by law according to the nature of the case. Understanding the person’s legal status, the conduct under investigation, the evidence, and the procedures taken is therefore important from this stage. When Is a Criminal Case Referred to Court? The existence of a complaint or investigation does not mean that conviction is presumed. The Public Prosecution investigates the matter and then disposes of it in accordance with the law. The Criminal Procedure Law regulates the disposition of a case following investigation, including orders that there is no ground to institute criminal proceedings in the circumstances prescribed by law, as well as referral to the competent court. It is therefore important to distinguish between: A complaint. An investigation. Referral to court. And a judgment of conviction or acquittal. Each represents a different legal stage. Criminal Lawyer Before the Court Once a criminal case is referred to court, another stage of legal work begins. The charge, case papers, investigation records, reports, documents, and evidence must be reviewed before determining the legal issues that may be raised. The defense may concern the facts themselves. It may concern the evidence. It may concern procedure. It may concern intent. It may concern the legal classification of the conduct. In some cases, several of these issues may arise together. Court advocacy is therefore not the beginning of the defense. The real beginning is understanding the case file. Criminal Appeals: Do Not Treat Time as a Waiting Period When a judgment is issued, the period that follows should not simply be treated as time to wait and think. The available avenue of appeal or challenge, together with the applicable deadlines and procedures, should be identified according to the type of judgment and the case. Reviewing the judgment may require examining: The reasons for the judgment. The evidence relied upon. The accused person’s defense. The arguments that were raised. How the judgment dealt with those arguments. And the case papers. Only then can the legal grounds available for a challenge be properly assessed. Time becomes particularly important when the convicted person is detained or imprisoned and may not personally be able to obtain documents or follow all procedures easily. Time after judgment can itself become part of the defense strategy. How Do You Choose the Best Drug Crimes Lawyer in the UAE? If you are looking for a lawyer for a drug-related case, do not make promises of acquittal or dismissal of the case your selection criterion. Look for a lawyer who can examine the file on several levels: Facts: What happened? Procedure: How did the arrest, search, and seizure take place? Evidence: What seized items, reports, and other evidence exist? Attribution: What connects the accused to the alleged act or seized substances? Intent: What is the evidence intended to establish? Legal classification: Which legal provisions apply? Stage of proceedings: Is the case before the police, Public Prosecution, court, or at the appeal stage? When these elements are examined together, the defense is built around the actual case rather than a standard template used for every matter. Can a Lawyer Guarantee an Acquittal? No. A lawyer does not have the authority to issue a judgment. The lawyer’s role is to examine the case, evidence, and procedures, submit appropriate legal arguments and applications, and represent the client in accordance with the law. The determination of the case belongs to the judiciary. Therefore, the professional approach is not: “I guarantee an acquittal.” It is: “Let me review the case file first.” What Should You Bring to a Criminal Lawyer Consultation? The more complete the information and documentation, the more accurately the case can be assessed. Depending on the stage of proceedings, useful materials may include: The complaint or case number. Available documents. Available decisions or orders. A copy of the judgment, if one has been issued. Reports. Correspondence or digital evidence related to the matter. A clear timeline of what happened. A document or fact should not be withheld simply because the person believes it may harm their position. The lawyer needs the complete picture in order to assess the case properly. Mistakes to Avoid in a Criminal Case Certain actions may make a legal situation more complicated, including: Deleting or altering evidence. Publishing details of the case on social media. Contacting other parties in a way that may create a new legal issue. Relying on another person’s experience as if it guarantees the same result in your case. Delaying legal advice until statutory deadlines are approaching. Assuming that similar charges necessarily mean similar cases or judgments. Every case must be examined according to its own facts, evidence, and circumstances. Advocate and Legal Consultant Ali Saeed Al Shamsi – Criminal Cases Advocate and Legal Consultant Ali Saeed Al Shamsi is a UAE lawyer whose legal practice includes criminal matters and the examination of case files, procedures, evidence, legal defenses, and available legal remedies according to the circumstances of each case. Assessment begins by understanding the facts and the stage reached by the proceedings, followed by examination of the relevant documents and evidence. A case that appears straightforward from a brief account may look very different once its papers are reviewed. Likewise, a case that initially appears difficult may take on a different character after the complete file is examined. Therefore, the first question in a criminal case should not be: Will I win? It should be: What is actually in the case file? Frequently Asked Questions About Criminal Lawyers in the UAE Who Is the Best Criminal Lawyer in the UAE? There is no official authority that awards a lawyer the title of “best criminal lawyer in the UAE.” A more appropriate approach is to choose a licensed lawyer capable of examining the type of case, its stage, evidence, procedures, strengths, and risks clearly. How Do I Choose a Criminal Lawyer in Abu Dhabi? Look for a licensed lawyer with experience handling criminal matters and seek an assessment after the lawyer has reviewed the facts, documents, and evidence rather than relying solely on advertising or promises. When Do I Need a Criminal Lawyer? Legal advice may become important from the complaint, preliminary inquiry, or investigation stage and may continue through the Public Prosecution, trial, appeal, and further challenges depending on the circumstances of the case. How Do I Choose a Drug Crimes Lawyer in Abu Dhabi? Look for a lawyer capable of examining the charge, seized substances, arrest and search procedures, preservation of evidence, forensic reports, intent, other evidence, and the proper legal classification rather than focusing only on the potential punishment. Do All Drug Cases Carry the Same Penalty? No. Cases differ according to the conduct attributed to the accused, type of substance, facts, evidence, intent, legal classification, and the legislation in force that applies to the particular circumstances. Do I Need a Lawyer During a Public Prosecution Investigation? Every case is different. UAE Criminal Procedure Law regulates the presence of defense counsel during investigation and access to case papers in accordance with the provisions and limitations prescribed by law. Can a Lawyer Get a Criminal Case Dismissed? No outcome in a criminal case can be guaranteed in advance. A lawyer’s role is to examine the file and identify available legal arguments, applications, and options. Decisions concerning the proceedings and the final determination of the case belong to the competent judicial authorities according to the relevant stage. Can a Lawyer Guarantee an Acquittal? No. A lawyer can provide legal defense, examine evidence and procedures, and represent the client. The final judgment is issued by the competent court. Why Is It Important to Consult a Lawyer After a Judgment? Where a legal avenue of appeal or challenge is available, the judgment, its reasoning, the evidence, previous defense arguments, and applicable deadlines should be examined without unnecessary delay. Conclusion If you are searching for the “best criminal lawyer in Abu Dhabi,” a “criminal lawyer in the UAE,” or a “drug crimes lawyer,” do not make your only question: Who is the best? Start with the questions that reveal the true nature of the case: What is the charge? What are the facts? What evidence exists? How was the evidence obtained? What stage have the proceedings reached? What is the proper legal classification? What legal options are available? In criminal cases, the strength of a defense is not measured by the size of the promises made or the length of the courtroom argument. The proper starting point can be summarized as: Facts + Procedure + Evidence + Legal Classification = The Foundation of the Defense Choosing the right lawyer therefore begins with finding someone who can properly read and understand the case file before building the defense. Relevant UAE Legislation Federal Decree-Law No. (38) of 2022 Promulgating the Criminal Procedure Law, as amended. Federal Decree-Law No. (31) of 2021 Promulgating the Crimes and Penalties Law, as amended. Federal Decree-Law No. (30) of 2021 on Combating Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances, as amended. Federal Decree-Law No. (34) of 2022 Regulating the Legal Profession and Legal Consultation Profession, together with its implementing regulations and decisions. Prepared by: Advocate and Legal Consultant Ali Saeed Al Shamsi This article is provided for general legal awareness only. It does not guarantee the outcome of any case and does not replace an independent review of the facts, documents, evidence, and applicable legislation in force in the United Arab Emirates.
Read Article
Penalties for Online Insult and Defamation in the UAE via WhatsApp and Social Media
Penalty for Online Insult and Defamation in the UAE via WhatsApp and Social Media What Is the Penalty for Online Insult and Defamation in the UAE? A case may begin with a message written in a few seconds, a comment on a post, or a voice message sent in a WhatsApp group. However, when electronic means are used, it is necessary to determine the applicable legal provision before determining the penalty. The issue does not depend merely on whether offensive words were used. The following factors should be considered: Content of the statement + context + means used + person to whom the statement was directed + evidence + manner in which the content was sent or published. UAE law contains specific provisions governing insult and defamation committed through an information network, information technology means, or information system. Penalty for Online Insult and Defamation in the UAE Article (43) of Federal Decree-Law No. 34 of 2021 on Combating Rumours and Cybercrimes criminalizes insulting another person or attributing to another person a fact that would expose that person to punishment or contempt by others through an information network, information technology means, or information system. The penalty is: Imprisonment and a fine of not less than AED 250,000 and not more than AED 500,000, or either of these two penalties. Where any of the acts specified in the Article is committed against a public official or a person entrusted with a public service because of or in connection with the performance of their duties, this constitutes an aggravating circumstance. This demonstrates why the means through which the conduct occurred must be identified before determining the applicable penalty. What Is the Difference Between Online Insult and Defamation? The use of electronic means does not eliminate the legal distinction between insult and defamation. Insult: involves harming a person's honour or dignity without attributing a specific fact. Defamation: involves attributing a fact to a person that would expose that person to punishment or contempt. Where an information network or information technology means is used, the applicability of the UAE Cybercrime Law must also be considered. For a detailed explanation of this distinction, read: The Difference Between Insult and Defamation in UAE Law: Penalties and Cybercrime https://alilaw.ae/en/articles/16 Is Insulting Someone on WhatsApp a Crime in the UAE? Criminal liability may arise from an offensive statement sent through WhatsApp where the legal elements of the offence are satisfied. The incident may involve: A private message, WhatsApp group, voice message, image accompanied by a comment, video, or forwarded content. However, the mere presence of inappropriate language in a WhatsApp conversation does not automatically establish criminal liability. The entire message, its context, attribution to the sender, manner in which the evidence was obtained, and other surrounding circumstances should be examined. Is a Private WhatsApp Message Different From a WhatsApp Group? The circumstances may differ significantly. A message sent directly to one person is not necessarily identical in its circumstances to a statement published in a group containing several people. The presence of other persons, nature of the group, content of the statement, and manner in which it was sent or published may all be relevant when assessing the incident. However, the fact that a conversation is private does not by itself mean that electronic insult is legally permitted. Article (43) concerns the use of an information network, information technology means, or information system. Each incident must therefore be examined according to its own elements rather than merely being classified as a “private” or “public” conversation. Is Insult Through Instagram, Snapchat or TikTok a Crime? Electronic insult may occur through: A comment on a post, private message, story, public post, video, image accompanied by text, electronic account, or reposted content. The basic legal question does not change simply because a different application is used. The important question is: Was an information network or information technology means used to commit conduct satisfying the elements of a criminal offence? The nature of the content, available evidence, and surrounding circumstances must then be examined. Is Online Defamation the Same as Insult and Defamation? The term “online defamation” is commonly used to describe conduct that harms another person's reputation on the internet. However, the label used by a person does not determine the legal characterization of the incident. Depending on the content and manner in which the conduct occurred, the incident may involve insult, defamation, invasion of privacy, threats, or another offence. The correct starting point is therefore not merely: “I was defamed online.” Instead, the relevant questions are: What exactly happened? What content was sent or published? How was it communicated? Is Calling Someone a “Fraudster” on WhatsApp Insult or Defamation? A reliable legal conclusion cannot be reached by examining a single word without considering the complete statement and its context. A word may be used merely as an offensive description, or it may form part of a statement attributing a specific fact to another person. The distinction may affect the legal characterization of the conduct. Therefore, a fixed list of “insult or defamation words” cannot determine the legal outcome of every case. The law assesses the incident in its full meaning and context, not merely an isolated word. How Do You Prove Online Insult or Defamation? Messages, conversations, images, voice messages, posts, comments, and other digital content may form part of the evidence. However, the existence of electronic content alone does not resolve every evidentiary issue. It may be necessary to examine: Source of the evidence + attribution to its author + integrity of the content + completeness of the conversation + preceding and subsequent context + legality of obtaining the evidence + its relevance to the alleged offence. The original evidence should therefore be preserved as far as possible and should not be altered or tampered with. For further details regarding evidence and the period for filing a complaint, read: How to Prove Insult and Defamation in the UAE: Evidence and Time Limit for Filing a Complaint https://alilaw.ae/en/articles/20 Is a Screenshot Enough to Prove Online Insult? A screenshot may form part of the evidence presented in relation to an incident, but it does not automatically establish the offence. Questions may arise such as: Who owns the account? Is the screenshot complete or cropped? Has it been altered? What messages came before and after it? Can the content be attributed to the accused person? The evidentiary value of a screenshot is therefore assessed together with the other circumstances and evidence in the case. What Should I Do If I Am Insulted on WhatsApp or Social Media? One of the first mistakes to avoid is responding with another offensive statement. An angry response may transform a complaint by one party into allegations involving both parties. It is important to preserve the original content, avoid altering messages or images, retain the complete conversation where possible, record information associated with the relevant account or telephone number, and avoid republishing the offensive content unnecessarily. The date on which the victim became aware of the incident and the alleged perpetrator should also be identified, and the appropriate legal procedure should be considered without unnecessary delay. What Is the Time Limit for Filing an Insult or Defamation Complaint in the UAE? This is an important procedural issue. Article (11) of Federal Decree-Law No. 38 of 2022 Promulgating the Criminal Procedure Law includes insult and defamation among offences for which criminal proceedings are initiated upon a complaint by the victim, their legal representative, or specially authorized agent, in the circumstances covered by the provision. The Article also provides that a complaint shall not be accepted after three months from the date on which the victim became aware of the offence and its perpetrator, unless otherwise provided by law. It should therefore not be assumed that the time available to submit a complaint is unlimited. For further details, read: How to Prove Insult and Defamation in the UAE: Evidence and Time Limit for Filing a Complaint https://alilaw.ae/en/articles/20 Where Is an Insult or Defamation Complaint Filed? Under the UAE Criminal Procedure Law, a complaint may be submitted to the Public Prosecution or a judicial police officer, subject to the applicable legal provisions. The competent authority in a particular case may depend on jurisdiction, location of the incident, and other circumstances. Does Deleting a WhatsApp Message or Social Media Post End the Case? Not necessarily. Deleting content after it has been sent or published does not automatically eliminate every trace of the incident or make it impossible to prove. Other messages, data, or evidence may remain and may be assessed by the competent authorities. Conversely, merely alleging that deleted content previously existed does not automatically establish its content or attribution to a particular person. Evidence therefore remains a central issue. Can Forwarding an Offensive Message Create Legal Liability? Caution should be exercised when forwarding or republishing content that harms another person. The statement: “I did not write it; I only forwarded it” should not be treated as a general rule excluding liability. The nature of the content, the person's conduct, manner of distribution, intention, surrounding circumstances, and potentially applicable legal provisions must all be examined. Can an Online Insult Case Result in Mutual Accusations? Yes. This may occur where the recipient responds with statements that themselves contain offensive content. The existence of a potential complaint against the first party does not give the other party immunity to commit another offence. It is generally safer to preserve the evidence and follow the appropriate legal procedure rather than respond with another insult. What If I Am Accused of Online Insult or Defamation? A defence should not be based solely on statements such as: “I was angry.” or: “It was only a private message.” Messages should not be deleted or altered. The legal assessment should begin with: Content + complete conversation + context + means used + attribution of the account or telephone number + evidence + applicable legal provision. The dispute may concern the meaning of the statement, attribution of the content, completeness of the evidence, context in which the statement was made, or the correct legal characterization of the incident. Can Online Insult and Defamation Cases Be Settled? The UAE Criminal Procedure Law regulates criminal reconciliation for offences specified by law, including offences under Articles (425), (426), and (427) of the Crimes and Penalties Law. However, where an electronic incident is involved, the applicable legal provision must first be identified before assuming that reconciliation provisions relating to another offence automatically apply. This distinction is important because the expression “insult and defamation case” may be used to describe incidents governed by different legal provisions. Can Compensation Be Claimed for Online Insult and Defamation? In addition to potential criminal liability, a civil claim for compensation may arise where the requirements of civil liability are satisfied and damage and causation are established. There is no general rule that every conviction automatically results in a fixed amount of compensation. The court considers the nature of the damage, circumstances of the incident, available evidence, and other elements of civil liability. For further details, read: Compensation for Insult and Defamation in the UAE: When Can a Victim Claim Compensation? https://alilaw.ae/en/articles/21 What Is the Difference Between Article 43 of the Cybercrime Law and Article 427 of the Crimes and Penalties Law? This is one of the most important issues when determining the penalty for insult and defamation. Article (427) of the Crimes and Penalties Law regulates certain forms of insult and defamation, including specified situations involving telephone communications, direct statements to the victim, or messages. Article (43) of the Cybercrime Law addresses insult or attribution of a fact through an information network, information technology means, or information system. The applicable provision and penalty should therefore not be selected merely according to the name of the application used. Legal characterization comes before determining the penalty. The manner in which the incident occurred, means used, content, and other elements should be examined to determine the applicable legal provision. Frequently Asked Questions About Online Insult and Defamation in the UAE What Is the Penalty for Online Insult in the UAE? Article (43) of the UAE Cybercrime Law provides for imprisonment and a fine ranging from AED 250,000 to AED 500,000, or either of these penalties, where the requirements of the Article are satisfied. Is Insult in a Private WhatsApp Message a Crime? Legal liability may arise where the elements of the offence are satisfied. Describing a conversation as private does not by itself automatically exclude liability. Is Insult in a WhatsApp Group More Serious? The number of people who received the content and the manner in which it was distributed may be relevant circumstances, but determining liability and the applicable penalty requires consideration of the relevant legal provision and all surrounding circumstances. Is Insult on Instagram, Snapchat or TikTok Punishable? Offensive conduct committed through these platforms may fall within the scope of cybercrime provisions where the elements of the applicable offence are satisfied. Can a Complaint Be Filed After Three Months? Article (11) of the Criminal Procedure Law provides, for the offences covered by the provision, that a complaint shall not be accepted after three months from the date on which the victim became aware of the offence and its perpetrator, unless otherwise provided by law. Does Deleting the Message Prevent Proof of the Offence? Not necessarily. This depends on the existence, integrity, evidentiary value, and attribution of other available evidence. Is a Screenshot Enough? A screenshot may form part of the evidence, but it does not necessarily resolve issues concerning source, attribution, context, or integrity of the content. Can I Respond to the Person Who Insulted Me? Responding with another offensive statement may create a separate legal issue or result in mutual allegations. Preserving the evidence and considering the appropriate legal procedure is generally preferable. Conclusion The penalty for online insult and defamation in the UAE should not be determined merely because an incident occurred through WhatsApp or another social media platform. Article (43) of the UAE Cybercrime Law contains specific provisions where an information network, information technology means, or information system is used, with a fine that may reach AED 500,000, together with imprisonment or either of these penalties as provided by law. However, determining liability comes before determining the penalty. It is necessary to establish: What was said? What was the context? How was the content sent or published? Who owns the account or telephone number? What evidence is available? When did the victim become aware of the offence and its perpetrator? An electronic message may take only seconds to send, but determining its legal consequences requires examination of the entire incident. For a detailed explanation of the underlying distinction, read: The Difference Between Insult and Defamation in UAE Law: Penalties and Cybercrime https://alilaw.ae/en/articles/16 Prepared by: Advocate & Legal Consultant Ali Saeed Al Shamsi This article is provided for general legal awareness and does not replace an independent assessment of the circumstances, documents, evidence, and applicable legal provisions of each case under the laws in force in the United Arab Emirates.
Read Article
How to Prove Insult and Defamation in the UAE: Evidence and Time Limit for Filing a Complaint
How to Prove Insult and Defamation in the UAE: Evidence and Time Limit for Filing a Complaint How Can You Prove Insult or Defamation in the UAE? In insult and defamation cases, knowing the penalty alone is not enough. The statement may appear clear, but the case still depends on a fundamental question: Can the incident be proven and attributed to the person who made the statement? The assessment of an insult or defamation case therefore usually begins with five elements: Statement + context + means used + attribution to the person responsible + evidence. Evidence becomes particularly important when the incident occurs through WhatsApp or social media, as the case may involve an electronic account, telephone number, deleted message, screenshot, or voice message. What Evidence Can Prove Insult and Defamation in the UAE? There is no single form of evidence suitable for every insult or defamation case. The method of proof depends on how the incident occurred. The statement may have been made directly to the victim, in the presence of others, over the telephone, in a private message, through WhatsApp, in an online group, in a comment or post, through a voice message, or through a social media account. The first step is therefore to determine how the alleged insult or defamation occurred, and then identify the available evidence that may prove the incident and attribute it to the person responsible. Is a Screenshot Enough to Prove Insult or Defamation? Screenshots are among the most common forms of evidence preserved after an online incident. However, the existence of a screenshot does not automatically resolve every evidentiary issue. Questions may arise such as: Who owns the account? Is the screenshot complete or cropped? Is the date of the message visible? Does it show the telephone number or account name? What came before and after the statement? Can the content be attributed to the person against whom the complaint is made? It is therefore preferable to preserve the original conversation or content and not rely solely on an isolated screenshot where the original remains available. How Do I Prove Insult Through WhatsApp? If the alleged insult occurred through WhatsApp, the conversation should, as far as possible, be preserved in its original form. Information that may be relevant includes: Telephone number + account name + date and time of messages + preceding and subsequent conversation + voice messages + images and files + group members, where relevant. The conversation should not be altered, reconstructed, or partially deleted, because context may be important when assessing the incident. For further details about liability and penalties involving WhatsApp and social media, read: Penalty for Online Insult and Defamation in the UAE via WhatsApp and Social Media https://alilaw.ae/en/articles/19 Is a Voice Note Evidence of Insult? A voice message may form an important part of the evidence. However, the existence of a recording or voice note does not automatically prove that it was sent by a particular person. It may be necessary to examine the source of the message, the account or telephone number from which it was sent, the context of the conversation, and other surrounding circumstances. Preserving the voice message in its original source may therefore be preferable to keeping only a separate copy. How Do I Prove Insult or Defamation on Instagram, Snapchat or TikTok? The incident may involve a comment, post, private message, temporary story, video, image accompanied by text, reposted content, or content published through an anonymous account. Where possible, information identifying the following should be preserved: Account + content + date + context + manner in which the content was accessed. Prompt preservation can be particularly important where electronic content may later be edited or deleted. What If the Person Deletes the Message or Post? Deleting content does not automatically make it impossible to prove the incident. There may be screenshots, messages, data, witnesses, or other forms of evidence relevant to the case. Conversely, merely claiming that a deleted post or message previously existed does not by itself prove its content or attribution to a particular person. The closer the preserved evidence is to its original source, the more useful it may be when assessing the incident. Is Recording the Conversation With Another Phone Better? Using another device may help demonstrate how the conversation appeared, but the strength of evidence is not determined simply by the number of photographs or recordings. The more important issue is preserving, as far as possible, the original source of the content, account or telephone number, date, and context. A large number of cropped images is not necessarily stronger than a clear original conversation whose source and context can be examined. Can Witnesses Prove Insult or Defamation? Witnesses may be relevant depending on the circumstances. If the statement was made in a gathering or another place in the presence of other people, their testimony may be relevant to what they heard or observed. However, the assessment of witness testimony and other evidence is a matter for the competent judicial authorities according to the circumstances of each case. Proving that a statement was made does not necessarily establish every element of the offence, because the legal characterization of the statement remains a separate issue. What If the Account That Published the Content Is Anonymous? Where content is published through an anonymous or pseudonymous account, attribution of the conduct to the person responsible may become one of the most important issues in the case. The name displayed on an account does not necessarily establish who created or used it. Depending on the circumstances, technical and legal procedures may be required to identify the person responsible for the account or its use. Is It Enough to Prove That the Accused Made the Statement? Not always. Proving that the statement originated from the accused is an important step, but the legal analysis does not end there. The content, context, and correct legal characterization of the statement must also be examined. The issue may be whether the statement attributes a specific fact to another person, merely harms their honour or dignity, or was made in a context that affects its legal meaning. For a detailed explanation of this distinction, read: The Difference Between Insult and Defamation in UAE Law: Penalties and Cybercrime https://alilaw.ae/en/articles/16 What Is the Time Limit for Filing an Insult or Defamation Complaint in the UAE? This is one of the most important procedural issues. Article (11) of Federal Decree-Law No. 38 of 2022 Promulgating the Criminal Procedure Law regulates offences requiring a complaint from the victim, their legal representative, or specially authorized agent, including insult and defamation in the circumstances covered by the provision. The Article further provides that a complaint: Shall not be accepted after three months from the date on which the victim became aware of the offence and its perpetrator, unless otherwise provided by law. The time limit should therefore not be assessed solely by looking at the date on which the statement was written. The date on which the victim became aware of both the offence and its perpetrator must be considered according to the circumstances. Delay in assessing the case may therefore have important procedural consequences. When Does the Three-Month Period Begin? According to Article (11), the period is linked to the date on which the victim became aware of the offence and its perpetrator. This can be particularly important in electronic cases. A person may discover the content on one date while the identity of the person behind the account remains unknown, or other circumstances may affect when knowledge of the perpetrator can be established. Determining when the period began in a particular case depends on its facts and the evidence relating to knowledge of the offence and its perpetrator. Where Is an Insult or Defamation Complaint Filed in the UAE? Under the UAE Criminal Procedure Law, a complaint may be submitted to the Public Prosecution or a judicial police officer, subject to the applicable legal provisions. The competent authority in a particular case may depend on the location of the incident, jurisdiction, and other relevant circumstances. Should I Go to the Police or the Public Prosecution? The UAE Criminal Procedure Law permits complaints to be submitted to the Public Prosecution or a judicial police officer in accordance with the applicable provisions. The most appropriate practical route may depend on the Emirate in which the incident occurred, the nature of the conduct, and the means used. The important point is not to allow uncertainty about the competent authority to result in ignoring the legal time limit for filing the complaint. What Should I Do Immediately After Being Insulted or Defamed? First: Do not respond with another insult. Then preserve the available evidence. As far as possible, do not delete the conversation, alter messages or images, or remove information identifying the account or telephone number. Preserve the date and time where visible and retain the complete conversation whenever possible. It is also preferable not to republish the offensive material unnecessarily, to identify when you became aware of the incident and its perpetrator, and not to delay assessing the appropriate legal procedure. Is Republishing the Offensive Content to Prove It a Good Idea? Caution is required. A victim may be tempted to publish the content on their own account to show others what was said about them. However, expanding the circulation of the content may raise additional legal issues depending on the nature of the material. As a practical rule, preserve the evidence rather than unnecessarily expanding its publication. What Should I Do If the Conversation Is Very Long? Do not isolate the disputed statement and delete the rest of the conversation. The preceding and subsequent context may be important in understanding the meaning of the statement. It is preferable to preserve the complete conversation where possible and identify the portion relevant to the complaint without destroying the surrounding context. This is relevant to both the complainant and the accused because a proper assessment requires the statement to be understood in context. What If the Victim Responded With an Insult? Responding with offensive statements may result in mutual allegations or complaints depending on what each party said. A previous insult should not be treated as permission to respond with another potentially unlawful statement. Preserving the evidence and following the appropriate legal procedure is generally preferable. How Can an Accused Person Defend an Insult or Defamation Case? A defence should not begin by focusing only on one disputed word. The following should be reviewed: Statement + complete conversation + context + source of the evidence + attribution of the account or telephone number + manner in which the evidence was obtained + applicable legal provision. The dispute may concern attribution of the content to the accused, completeness of the conversation, meaning of the statement, context, or correct legal characterization. The complete file should therefore be assessed before a defence is formulated. Is Every Screenshot or Electronic Message Conclusive Evidence? No. Electronic evidence may have significant evidentiary value, but its strength may depend on its integrity, source, attribution, context, and the other evidence available. It is therefore incorrect to assume that a screenshot is always conclusive evidence, just as it is incorrect to assume that screenshots have no evidentiary value at all. The evidence must be assessed in light of the case as a whole. What Is the Difference Between Proving the Incident and Its Legal Characterization? This distinction is important. A person may successfully prove that a particular statement was made by another person. A separate question then remains: What is the legal characterization of that statement? Is it insult? Is it defamation? Was it committed using information technology? Does it relate to another offence? Proving that the statement was made does not eliminate the need to determine its correct legal characterization. Can Compensation Be Claimed After Proving Insult or Defamation? An insult or defamation incident may also give rise to a claim for compensation where the requirements of civil liability are satisfied and damage and causation are established. However, proving a message or publication does not automatically entitle the claimant to a particular amount of compensation. Compensation is a separate issue that depends on the nature of the damage, available evidence, circumstances of the case, and the court's assessment. For further details, read: Compensation for Insult and Defamation in the UAE: When Can a Victim Claim Compensation? https://alilaw.ae/en/articles/21 Frequently Asked Questions About Proving Insult and Defamation in the UAE Is a Screenshot Enough to Prove Insult? It may form part of the evidence, but its strength depends on its source, integrity, attribution, context, and other available evidence. Are WhatsApp Messages Evidence? WhatsApp messages may be relevant evidence, subject to examination of their attribution, context, integrity, and other circumstances of the case. Is a Voice Note Evidence? A voice note may form part of the evidence, but its source, attribution to the person concerned, and context should be examined. Can a Deleted Post Be Proven? Other evidence relating to deleted content may exist, but this depends on what has been preserved and whether its content and attribution can be established. How Long Do I Have to File an Insult or Defamation Complaint? Under Article (11) of the Criminal Procedure Law, in the circumstances covered by the provision, a complaint shall not be accepted after three months from the date on which the victim became aware of the offence and its perpetrator, unless otherwise provided by law. Where Do I File an Insult or Defamation Complaint? Under the Criminal Procedure Law, the complaint may be submitted to the Public Prosecution or a judicial police officer, subject to the applicable legal provisions. Does the Three-Month Period Begin on the Date of the Message? Not necessarily. The provision links the period to the date on which the victim became aware of the offence and its perpetrator. The date of knowledge must therefore be assessed according to the circumstances. Does Deleting the Message End the Case? Not necessarily. Other evidence may exist, although the content and its attribution must still be established according to the circumstances of the case. Can Compensation Be Claimed After Proving Insult or Defamation? A compensation claim may be considered where the requirements of civil liability are satisfied and damage and causation are established. The amount of compensation is subject to the court's assessment. Conclusion In insult and defamation cases, the question is not only: What did the person say? It is also: How can it be proven that the person said it? The strength of a case may therefore depend on the integrity, source, context, and attribution of the evidence. Where the incident occurred electronically, it is important, as far as possible, to preserve: Original conversation + account or telephone number + date + context + content connected with the incident. Attention should also be given to the legal time limit for filing a complaint. Article (11) of the Criminal Procedure Law provides, in the circumstances covered by the provision, that a complaint shall not be accepted after three months from the date on which the victim became aware of the offence and its perpetrator, unless otherwise provided by law. For a complete understanding of the subject, read: The Difference Between Insult and Defamation in UAE Law: Penalties and Cybercrime https://alilaw.ae/en/articles/16 Penalty for Online Insult and Defamation in the UAE via WhatsApp and Social Media https://alilaw.ae/en/articles/19 Compensation for Insult and Defamation in the UAE: When Can a Victim Claim Compensation? https://alilaw.ae/en/articles/21 Prepared by: Advocate & Legal Consultant Ali Saeed Al Shamsi This article is provided for general legal awareness and does not replace an independent assessment of the circumstances, documents, evidence, and applicable legal provisions of each case under the laws in force in the United Arab Emirates.
Read Article
Compensation for Insult and Defamation in the UAE: When Can a Victim Claim Compensation?
Compensation for Insult and Defamation in the UAE: When Can a Victim Claim Compensation? Can a victim claim compensation for insult and defamation in the UAE? Is there a fixed amount of compensation? Does a criminal fine awarded against the offender go to the victim? These questions frequently arise in insult and defamation cases, particularly where the offence occurs through WhatsApp or social media. The fundamental distinction is: A criminal penalty and civil compensation for damage are two different matters. A fine imposed on an offender does not mean that the amount of the fine becomes compensation payable to the victim. Likewise, establishing a criminal offence does not automatically entitle the victim to a fixed amount of compensation. A compensation claim depends on the damage suffered by the victim, the causal relationship between the wrongful act and that damage, and the other requirements of civil liability. Can a Victim Claim Compensation for Insult or Defamation? In principle, an act of insult or defamation may give rise to civil liability in addition to criminal liability where the applicable legal requirements are satisfied. UAE civil law recognizes that civil liability may exist alongside criminal liability where their respective requirements are met. Accordingly, the issue does not end with the question: Was a criminal offence committed? For compensation purposes, another important question arises: What damage did the victim suffer as a result of the act? What Is the Difference Between a Fine and Compensation? This distinction is frequently misunderstood. A fine: is a criminal penalty imposed by the court under the applicable criminal provision. Compensation: is a civil remedy for damage suffered by an injured person where the requirements of civil liability are established. Therefore, if a court orders an offender to pay a particular fine, that amount does not automatically become compensation payable to the victim. A separate civil claim, or a civil claim associated with criminal proceedings where legally permitted, may be available for compensation for the damage suffered. What Types of Damage May Be Compensated? Damage is not limited to direct financial loss. It may include material damage as well as moral damage. This distinction is particularly relevant to insult and defamation cases because the UAE Civil Transactions Law recognizes moral damage involving harm to a person's: honour, reputation, social standing, or financial consideration. These forms of harm are directly relevant to many cases involving insult, defamation, and damage to reputation. What Is Moral Damage in Insult and Defamation Cases? Moral damage does not necessarily involve the loss of a specific amount of money. An offensive statement may affect a person's honour, reputation, dignity, or social standing. However, merely stating: “I suffered psychological and moral harm” does not automatically establish an entitlement to a particular amount of compensation. The court considers the incident, the damage, the circumstances of the case, the evidence, and the causal relationship between the wrongful act and the alleged harm when assessing compensation. Is There a Fixed Amount of Compensation for Insult and Defamation in the UAE? No general rule provides a fixed amount payable in every insult or defamation case. It would therefore be inaccurate to say that every insult case automatically results in compensation of AED 10,000, AED 50,000, AED 100,000, or any other predetermined amount. The amount of compensation depends on the circumstances of each case and the damage established before the court. Two cases that appear similar may therefore result in different compensation awards. How Does the Court Determine the Amount of Compensation? Under the UAE Civil Transactions Law, compensation is assessed according to the damage suffered and the loss of profit where this is a natural consequence of the harmful act. Depending on the case, relevant considerations may include: The nature of the offensive conduct. The extent of the damage. The circumstances in which the incident occurred. Its effect on the victim. The extent to which the content was circulated. The evidence submitted. The causal relationship between the act and the alleged damage. There is no single mathematical formula applicable to every insult or defamation case. Can the Spread of Offensive Content on Social Media Affect Compensation? The manner and extent of publication may be relevant when assessing damage. A statement sent within a limited private context is not necessarily equivalent in its practical effect to content published to a large audience or widely circulated online. However, the number of views alone does not automatically determine the amount of compensation. The damage and its causal connection with the wrongful conduct must still be established in light of the circumstances of the case. For more information about online insult and defamation, see: Penalties for Online Insult and Defamation in the UAE via WhatsApp and Social Media https://alilaw.ae/ar/articles/19 Can Compensation Be Awarded for Insult Through WhatsApp? Insult or defamation through WhatsApp may give rise to criminal and civil consequences where the requirements of each form of liability are established. In a recent Abu Dhabi case, a court ordered a person to pay AED 10,000 in compensation for material and moral damage arising from conduct involving insult, defamation, and threats through WhatsApp, although the claimant had sought a higher amount. This illustrates an important practical principle: The amount claimed by a claimant is not necessarily the amount the court will award. The court ultimately determines compensation according to the damage established and the circumstances of the case. Does a Criminal Conviction Automatically Result in Compensation? Not automatically. Criminal liability and the assessment of civil compensation must be distinguished. A criminal judgment may have important legal consequences, but the amount of civil compensation is not automatically derived from the criminal fine or penalty. The court considering compensation examines the damage, its connection with the wrongful act, and the other legal requirements for civil liability. Can Compensation Be Claimed During Criminal Proceedings? The UAE Criminal Procedure Law regulates civil claims arising from criminal offences. In principle, a person who suffers direct personal damage from an offence may claim civil rights in accordance with the procedures and stages prescribed by law. The law also permits a civil claim for compensation arising from an offence to be brought before the criminal court for consideration together with the criminal case, subject to the applicable legal rules and procedures. The appropriate course depends on the stage of the proceedings and the circumstances of the individual case. Can a Separate Civil Compensation Claim Be Filed? A compensation claim may, depending on the circumstances and previous proceedings, be pursued through civil proceedings under the applicable legal rules. It should not therefore be assumed that there is only one route for claiming compensation in every insult or defamation case. Relevant questions include: Is there an existing criminal case? What stage has it reached? Has a judgment been issued? Has a civil claim already been made? What damage is being claimed? What Must Be Proven to Obtain Compensation? Claiming a large amount alone is not sufficient. The compensation claim must be supported by the damage and its relationship to the wrongful act. Relevant matters may include: Proof of the incident. Attribution of the conduct to the responsible person. Proof of damage. Establishing causation between the conduct and the damage. Relevant evidence and supporting documents. Proving the underlying insult or defamation is therefore an important foundation before assessing its consequences. For more information about screenshots, WhatsApp messages, voice notes, evidence, and the complaint period, see: How to Prove Insult and Defamation in the UAE: Evidence and Time Limit for Filing a Complaint https://alilaw.ae/ar/articles/20 Is a Screenshot Enough to Claim Compensation? A screenshot may form part of the evidence establishing the incident, but it does not automatically establish every element required for compensation. The case may require examination of: The source of the content + attribution + context + damage + causal relationship between the conduct and the damage. Proving that a statement existed is therefore different from proving all elements of the damage for which compensation is claimed. Can Compensation Be Claimed for Psychological and Moral Harm? Moral damage may fall within the scope of compensable harm under UAE law. The Civil Transactions Law expressly recognizes forms of moral damage involving harm to honour, reputation, social standing, and financial consideration. However, the existence and extent of such damage, and the amount of compensation awarded, depend on the circumstances and evidence in each case. Does an Apology Cancel the Right to Compensation? There is no general rule under which an apology automatically eliminates all legal consequences of an incident. An apology, settlement, waiver, or subsequent conduct by the parties may have different legal effects depending on the nature of the case, its procedural stage, and the steps already taken. The effect of any settlement, waiver, or agreement should therefore be assessed according to the circumstances of the particular case. Does Deleting a Post Prevent a Compensation Claim? Deleting a post or message does not necessarily eliminate damage that may already have occurred. However, proving the content, its circulation, and its consequences remains important. Evidence should therefore be preserved before online content disappears or is modified. Can Criminal Penalties and Civil Compensation Apply Together? Criminal liability and civil liability are distinct. An act may give rise to criminal liability where the elements of an offence are established, while civil liability may also arise where its separate requirements are satisfied. Accordingly, there may be both: A criminal penalty and A civil claim for compensation where permitted by law and supported by the facts. Does an Acquittal Always Prevent a Compensation Claim? No single rule should be applied to every acquittal. The effect of a criminal judgment on a civil compensation claim may depend on the basis of the judgment, its reasoning, its legal effect, and the issues that were conclusively determined. The judgment and its reasons should therefore be examined before determining its effect on a compensation claim. What Is the Time Limit for Claiming Compensation? The time limit for filing a criminal complaint should not be confused with the rules governing a civil claim for compensation arising from a harmful act. These are separate legal issues. The UAE Civil Transactions Law regulates the period applicable to claims arising from harmful acts and also contains provisions relevant where the compensation claim arises from a criminal offence. Accordingly, the criminal complaint period applicable to insult and defamation should not automatically be applied to a civil compensation claim. For information about the criminal complaint period, see: How to Prove Insult and Defamation in the UAE: Evidence and Time Limit for Filing a Complaint https://alilaw.ae/ar/articles/20 What Is the Difference Between Insult and Defamation Before Claiming Compensation? Before considering compensation, the legal characterization of the underlying conduct should first be understood. Defamation generally involves attributing a fact to another person that may expose that person to punishment or contempt, whereas insult involves harming a person's honour or dignity without attributing a specific fact. The applicable legal provisions may also differ depending on the method used to commit the conduct. For a detailed explanation, see the main article: The Difference Between Insult and Defamation in UAE Law: Penalties and Cybercrime https://alilaw.ae/ar/articles/16 Frequently Asked Questions About Compensation for Insult and Defamation in the UAE Can I Claim Compensation If I Have Been Insulted? A right to compensation may arise where the requirements of civil liability are satisfied and damage and causation are established. How Much Compensation Is Awarded for Insult and Defamation in the UAE? There is no fixed amount applicable to all cases. Compensation depends on the proven damage, circumstances, and evidence. Does the Criminal Fine Go to the Victim? No. A criminal fine must be distinguished from civil compensation payable to an injured person where the legal requirements for compensation are satisfied. Can Compensation Be Claimed for Moral Damage? Yes. UAE law recognizes moral damage, including harm to honour, reputation, social standing, and financial consideration. Can Compensation Be Claimed for Insult Through WhatsApp? Civil liability may arise from online abuse where its legal requirements are established. Does a Criminal Conviction Mean the Court Will Award the Full Amount I Claim? No. The amount claimed does not bind the court. Compensation is assessed according to the proven damage and circumstances of the case. Is a Screenshot Enough to Obtain Compensation? It may form part of the evidence, but it does not automatically establish every element of liability and damage. Can Compensation Be Claimed Before the Criminal Court? The UAE Criminal Procedure Law regulates civil claims arising from criminal offences and the applicable procedures for making such claims. Does Deleting the Post Prevent Compensation? Not necessarily. Damage may have occurred before deletion, although the incident and resulting damage must still be established. Is the Compensation Time Limit the Same as the Time Limit for Filing an Insult or Defamation Complaint? No. The criminal complaint period and the rules governing a civil compensation claim are distinct legal matters. Conclusion Compensation for insult and defamation in the UAE is not based on a fixed amount and should not be confused with a criminal fine. The basic framework is: Wrongful act + liability + damage + causation = the basis for considering compensation. Damage may be material or moral. Under UAE civil law, moral damage may include harm to honour, reputation, social standing, and financial consideration. The amount requested by a claimant does not mean that the court will award that amount in full. Compensation is assessed according to the damage established and the circumstances of each case. For a complete understanding of the subject, see: The Difference Between Insult and Defamation in UAE Law: Penalties and Cybercrimehttps://alilaw.ae/ar/articles/16 Penalties for Online Insult and Defamation in the UAE via WhatsApp and Social Mediahttps://alilaw.ae/ar/articles/19 How to Prove Insult and Defamation in the UAE: Evidence and Time Limit for Filing a Complainthttps://alilaw.ae/ar/articles/20 Prepared by: Advocate & Legal Consultant Ali Saeed Al Shamsi This article is provided for general legal awareness and does not replace an individual assessment of the facts, documents, evidence, judgments, and applicable legislation in the United Arab Emirates.
Read Article